Latest News

Greetings to all NSAC members from the President!
It is hard to believe that the harvest season is here for many of our members! It does not seem that long ago that we were all talking about the wet/dry, hot/cold weather than seemed to stay around...
Read More >>

COSO Releases Updated Enterprise Risk Management Framework
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission released a long-awaited update Wednesday to its ERM Framework: Enterprise Risk Management–Integrating with Strategy and...
Read More >>

3 Steps To Protecting Your Business From Workplace Fraud
Every few months, a major fraud investigation hits the news. According to a new report titled Keeping Business Clean: A CGMA Guide to Countering Fraud & Corruption by the Association of...
Read More >>

Companies shouldn't rush to adopt new hedge accounting standard
The Financial Accounting Standards Board released its long-awaited hedge accounting standard this week, but companies may want to be careful about adopting it early, or else they could miss out on...
Read More >>

Embezzlement by Employees
In the cult film "Office Space", workers at a technology company seek revenge for boring jobs and bad treatment by ripping off their employer via software that skims fractions of pennies with each...
Read More >>

View News Archives >>

Contractor or Employee?

Published on March 30, 2017

Your business is booming. You need to hire help. But should your new hire be an employee or an independent contractor?

Many businesses prefer to classify workers as independent contractors so they don't have to pay payroll taxes, provide benefits or be subject to labor laws such as overtime pay. Some workers, too, want to be classified as independent contractors so they don’t have payroll taxes deducted from each check (though they are still responsible for them), many of their business expenses are tax deductible, and they may have more flexibility in their working conditions.

Employment laws, however, restrict those choices even if both you and the worker agree. If you misclassify someone as an independent contractor when they should have been treated as an employee, the IRS will hit you hard with penalties and back taxes.

So let’s try to clear up a bit of confusion, although clarity is hard to find in the murky waters of defining employee status.

The primary issue the Internal Revenue Service uses to determine employee status is who “controls” the worker. The agency looks at three main areas:

1. Behavioral. Does the worker control how he or she does the work? Who determines when and where the employee works? Who controls the order or sequence of work processes?

2. Type of relationship. Is the work performed a critical and regular part of the business? How permanent is the relationship?

3. Financial. Does the worker have a significant investment? In other words, does he or she own their own work tools? Do they make their services available to others or do they work for other businesses?

In the decisions determining that workers should be considered employees rather than independent contractors, the issues seemed to come down to whether the work was essential to the business.

These issues are certain to need clarification in the next few years. As a business operator, you'd be wise to consult an attorney before hiring. For now, as you’re trying to decide whether to hire an employee or engage an independent contractor in your business, keep these points in mind:

Employees GENERALLY:

• Work at your location.

• Work hours specified by you.

• Work per your instructions.

• Use equipment provided by you.

• Are paid for their labor regardless of business performance.

• Work for you on a continuing basis.

• Are usually paid by unit of time (hourly, monthly).

• Can quit or be fired at any time.

 

Independent contractors GENERALLY:

• Are independent business people, especially if they are incorporated.

• Choose where and when they work.

• Control how they perform their services.

• Can earn a profit or suffer a loss.

• May manage multiple clients or customers.

• Work for you on an as-needed basis.

• Can be terminated or leave, according to the terms of their agreement with you.

 

Reviewed March 21, 2016